‘Superman’: The Godfather of the Modern Superhero Film

by Jen Seggio

On December 15th, 1978, Richard Donner made the world believe a man could fly. Superman was a watershed in special effects, music, and most importantly, how we see superheroes on the big screen. In a world saturated with DC and Marvel epics, it’s easy to forget its impact on the genre. On this day, its 40th anniversary, let’s look at why Superman is the godfather of the modern superhero film and how much has changed since it flew into theaters.

The Original Origin Story

Every feature that introduces us to a new force for good follows the same path that Superman forged. We meet our hero, witness his call to action and evolution through montage. We meet friends, foes and assorted faces that make up the spectrum of his world between each plot point. After facing his first challenge, our hero comes to grips with the villain. Before he can save the day, he’s plunged into his lowest point. Everything culminates in a tense climax that tests our hero’s physical and mental limits. It even takes a big risk by setting up the sequel, in the very first scene no less.

This Joseph Campbell-style adventure appears simplistic, but Superman proved that comic book flicks can have deep, resonating themes. Responsibility over the power we wield is a major one. Spider-Man may have coined a catchphrase to go along with this theme, but Superman was the first to contemplate it. After the Kents adopt baby Clark, we skip ahead to his teenage years. He already has full control of his powers and he uses them at least once to impress his peers. It’s up to Pa Kent and his untimely passing to teach him that superpowers can’t always save the day. When given the gifts Clark has, there’s always the danger of allowing unchecked desires to govern our actions, as the Donner cut of Superman II later reveals.

Image via movie-screencaps.com

A Savior in More Ways Than One

The biggest theme running through the feature is the biblical one. Kal-El’s origins when summed up amounts to “Space Moses”; an infant exiled from his homeworld and raised by strangers grows up into a powerful leader. The movie takes it a step further by elevating Superman into a Christ-like figure. Jor-El purposefully sends his only son to Earth to make him an example of hope for humanity. Both Clark Kent and Superman try to see the good in every person they meet, even attempting to reason with criminals before stopping them. When handing a burglar over to a cop, Superman lightly jokes “Confession’s good for the soul, you might want to listen to him”. And Perry White, in the most overt comparison, calls the chance to speak with Superman “the most important interview since Moses talked to God”.

For better or worse, the image of “Space Jesus” has stuck with Supes thanks to this movie. It’s this portrayal that has made him difficult for some viewers to relate to him. A common complaint is his godliness makes him “boring”. I think a more valid interpretation of Superman’s adventures is his struggle to stay good and selfless despite mankind’s flaws and his own human desires. The movie explores this through dialogue and character as opposed to cutting right to the action. It’s that contemplative approach that allows us to really know the characters and feel for their plight. It also makes the buildup in the action scenes that much more exciting.

Image va movie-screencaps.com

High-Flying Fun

The mood shift between serious business and campy fun is uneven thanks to Donner and producer Alexander Salkind’s opposing visions; Salkind wanted something akin to 60’s Batman while Donner clamored for a more grounded hero. They would clash even harder during the production of Superman II, but that’s a story for another time. That’s not to say the humor is unwelcome, however. Like any good superhero movie, it knows when to poke a little fun at itself. The first time Clark goes to change into his iconic costume, the lack of convenient phone booths catches him off guard. He has to settle for a swiftly revolving door. The way Christopher Reeve delivers his one-liners just can’t help but make you smile.

On that note, the casting is impeccable. I don’t see actors pretending to be heroes and damsels, I see Clark, Lois, Lex come to life on screen. As I mentioned before, Christopher Reeve is congenial as both the heroic Superman and sweet, mild-mannered Clark Kent. Gene Hackman in particular looks like he’s having a ball as the irredeemably wicked “criminal mastermind” Lex Luthor. When his moll Miss Tessmacher informs him that one of his stolen missiles will hit the city where her mother lives, he responds with a careless head shake as if to say “She won’t in a few minutes”. His foil, Otis, is one of the best worst sidekicks a villain could have. Of course, one can’t forget John Williams’ soaring musical score. Simply put it’s one of the greatest musical orchestrations of all time. You hear the opening notes, and you know Superman is on his way.

Image via movie-screencaps.org

Up, Up and Away From the Past

Admittedly there are some things that date the movie (and I’m not just talking stylistic choices like costuming or dialogue). Everyone has pointed out at least once how laughably thin Clark Kent’s disguise is. His bumbling human persona versus his idolized super one has birthed one of the most annoying love “triangles”. Iron Man put the kibosh on all the problems that come with keeping a secret identity by ditching it altogether; when Tony Stark tossed those cue cards, he freed nearly every Marvel hero from the tired clichés of secret keeping and easily avoidable misunderstandings. Yes, making their civilian identities publicly known has come with its own issues, but it’s been far more interesting to see those play out as opposed to the dull alternative.

Much of this stems from perhaps the one obstacle no incarnation of Superman has never truly overcome — Lois Lane. It’s difficult to see what Clark does in such a selfish, cynical, and not very bright woman who constantly puts herself in danger. Any and all charm that Lois has comes directly from Margot Kidder herself, a testament to her talent. Thanks to the MCU we’ve seen a welcome rise in engaging and empowered comic book heroines on the big screen including Black Widow, DC’s Wonder Woman, Scarlet Witch, Black Panther’s Okoye and Nakia, Thor Ragnarok’s Valkyrie, The Wasp, and hopefully, Captain Marvel. Lois is a relic by comparison. Women don’t fantasize about being damsels in distress anymore because they have the power and drive to rescue themselves now.

Image via movie-screencaps.com

A Friend From Another Star

Superman is an excellent introduction to the genre of superhero flicks. It’s a high stakes adventure that’s never without a good sense of humor. Now I didn’t grow up with Richard Donner’s Superman; the classic Fleischer Studios animated shorts served as my introduction to the Man of Steel. Yet Superman: The Movie makes me feel like a kid again when I watch it. Its grand, epic scope taps into the sensation of childhood wonder in a ways few films can and always keeps me returning. For those in my generation who haven’t watched it yet, don’t think of it as a time capsule. Without its iconic status, we wouldn’t have the superheroes we adore today.

Thank you for reading! What are you thoughts on Superman? Comment down below!

If you enjoyed this article, subscribe to MovieBabble via email to stay up to date on the latest content.

Join MovieBabble on Patreon so that new content will always be possible.

What movie topic should I discuss next? Whether it be old or new, the choice is up to you!

Related Articles


Film Review - Superman: Red Son (2020) | MovieBabble March 4, 2020 - 9:06 am

[…] hard to find someone who wouldn’t know what the Superman emblem looks like these days. However, over the decades, Superman has had his fair share of critics […]

Liz Gauffreau December 16, 2018 - 4:20 pm

Thank you so much, Jack–I really appreciate it!!

The Animation Commendation December 16, 2018 - 10:22 am

Just rewatched this the other day actually! A wonderful film even though I found the first 40 minutes (before Christopher Reeve appeared) to be quite boring.

coolcomix0221 December 15, 2018 - 5:38 pm

What a “swell” article! For a film that’s now 40 years old, it’s still amazing how it mainly holds up beyond its ’70s exterior. I recently saw this film (the 2 hour, 23 minute version, I think) in theaters as part of Fathom Events and it was a satisfying experience. Afterwards, I revisited Captain Logan and Oliver Harper’s reviews of this film and there was one thing that I agreed on. I’m talking about the ending where Superman couldn’t save Lois in time from being buried alive and he ends up spinning the Earth backwards to reverse time (despite Jor-El’s voice forbidding him) and redeem that. If she was saved but someone else (excluding Jimmy Olsen) got axed as a result of that action, I might have accepted it. It would have also set him up for Superman II that he has to put his self desires aside for the greater good.

Jack "Blimprider" Tyler December 15, 2018 - 12:39 pm

What a great review! You elegantly captured everything that made this movie head-and-shoulders above everything that had come before. I grew up on the George Reeves TV series, and loved him as a child, but as I aged, it did too, to the point where all my teenage self could see in the reruns were all the many flaws. That same teenager suffered through Adam West’s Batman; none of my friends nor I realized they were trying to be campy, we only saw an incredibly lousy TV show. The Saturday morning cartoons? Meh. The Green Hornet was in that era, and was a small cut above, but far from being enough to buck the tsunami of dreck that was the genre of that time. Then came Superman, and with a single stroke, the slate was wiped clean. Certainly, there have been some dogs since, even within the franchise, but none have been bad enough to return us to the days when superhero shows, movies, and animation were avoid-at-all-cost garbage. You are spot-on. Anyone who has enjoyed even one modern superhero movie from any franchise owes their love of the genre to this film, and the team that brought it to life. Thanks for this great tribute. I’ll be linking it on my Thursday roundup of Other Voices; it certainly deserves to be widely read!

Liz Gauffreau December 15, 2018 - 12:52 pm

I enjoyed your comment as much as I enjoyed the review! I will be adding “bucking the tsumani of dreck” to my snark lexicon.

Jack "Blimprider" Tyler December 15, 2018 - 1:19 pm

I’m glad you enjoyed it, but the main article was the inspiration. I just took a look at your page, and found that likeable myself, so I’m going to link it on my Thursday blog and see if I can get you a few more eyes on your work. Best of luck with your book, by the way!

Liz Gauffreau December 15, 2018 - 10:11 am

I saw this movie in the theater when it came out. Reading your review reminded me of how much I enjoyed Gene Hackman as Lex Luthor.

Nick Kush December 15, 2018 - 9:46 am

Join the MovieBabble staff: https://moviebabble971852905.wpcomstaging.com/join-moviebabble/

Like MovieBabble on Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/moviebabblereviews/

Follow MovieBabble on Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/moviebabble/

Follow MovieBabble on Twitter: https://twitter.com/MovieBabble_


Leave a Comment Below!

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: