In the film industry, a popular concept is drawing inspiration to preexisting material like books or video games, etc. Each type of adaptation has it draws, but also its downfalls. Now, there is a high chance of a book or series becoming a movie if it’s popular. Honestly, it would be more of surprise if the film industry didn’t capitalize from the success of books. Unfortunately, some adaptations fail to deliver.
But, the tough thing about these type of adaptations is that there are high expectations from fans of the book/series. Ultimately, this could mean even one small decision to deviate from the book could cause a lot of backlash. Now, this doesn’t stop production companies from taking on projects like this, but it does add the pressure.
While there have been very successful adaptations like the Harry Potter movies and The Hunger Games, there are many failures that tanked due to their deviation from the source material. Here are five disappointing book to movie adaptations.
The Mortal Instruments: City of Bones
Roughly ten years ago, Cassandra Clare graced the world with the first book in The Mortal Instruments series. Since the release of The City of Bones, the first novel, five other books have followed. In 2013, the movie for the first novel aired and tanked, badly. Unfortunately, the movie wasn’t as popular as anticipated. With so many books in the series, the goal was to have all of them on the big screen. After the poor acclaim of the first installment, the plans for the next movie were cancelled. As someone who read the book series, there were a few choices made that set the movie up for failure. Although it didn’t gain success on the big screen, it became a show called Shadowhunters. Ultimately, becoming a TV show was the right movie. In February, the second part of season 3 will air.
Following Divergent and Insurgent, the third installment in the Divergent series, Allegiant was a poor ending for the films. Ever since the first movie was announced, fans were excited to see the five factions come to life. Finally seeing the faction ceremony on screen and not just in their imagination was mind-boggling. Having Shailene Woodley bring Tris Prior to life was a whole other experience. But, the success of the trilogy relies on each individual movie prevailing.
The creative license and the idea to change a character death left a sour taste in many people’s mouth. In the third novel, Tris dies at the end and people who read the series before seeing the movie were expecting it. Yet, when the credits came for the third movie, Tris was still alive. Now, this decision, choosing to let a character live, alters the meaning behind the death and the characters reactions after. Unfortunately, this one decision brought the trilogy to a sad and unfulfilling end.
Garnering a measly 17 percent on Rotten Tomatoes, the movie adaptation to the first novel in Richelle Mead’s Vampire Academy series disappointed many. As one person accurately states in their personal review, “another young-adult adaptation bites the dust.” While book to movie creations are popular in the film industry, making them well-received is another story. For this movie in particular, many decisions contributed to the failure of this production. Honestly, the book series the movie is based on is amazing and, while it includes vampires, it is like no other series out there.
So, this begs the question: why did a great series not translate on-screen? At the core of it, is the decision to make the movie comedic, as Charlie Jane Anders brings to attention in his review. Taking the movie in this particular direction made it lose the meaning behind everything and made the movie a joke. Another big thing that took away from the movie was the casting. In the main cast, there were a few vital characters that didn’t meet the vision that the books created.
Honestly, these two movies are self-explanatory and definitely deserve to be on this list. Surprisingly, the second movie did better than the first even though it didn’t seem like the series was salvageable. Actually, people were relieved when the third movie was cancelled. For the first film, vital parts of the book were missing that took away from the awe that people found in the writing. Also, messing with characters and character traits took away from the story people were expecting.
In today’s society, The Shining is regarded as a great movie, but when looking at it in terms of a book to movie adaptation, it doesn’t add up. Even Stephen King, the author of the novel of the same name, doesn’t like the movie. Now, that fact should speak volumes about the movie. Compared to the other movies in the list, this one is popular, but that doesn’t excuse the fact that it doesn’t reflect the book as it should. King called the movie “a big, beautiful Cadillac with no engine inside it.” Ultimately, the lack of change in Jack Nicholson separates the movie from the book.
Thank you for reading! What do you think about some notoriously bad book to movie adaptations? Comment down below!
If you enjoyed this article, subscribe to MovieBabble via email to stay up to date on the latest content.
Join MovieBabble on Patreon so that new content will always be possible.
What movie topic should I discuss next? Whether it be old or new, the choice is up to you!