Netflix Does Hallmark in ‘Falling Inn Love’

by Brian Connor
Falling Inn Love

In July, Netflix released Secret Obsession, the streaming service’s take on a Lifetime movie. It….did not go well. The cast was weak, the story was not engaging, and it missed the whole point of a good Lifetime movie. Namely, to be insanely melodramatic. You watch Lifetime movies to see people chew scenery, and Brenda Song and Brick McHandsome or whatever the male lead’s name was didn’t go nearly nuts enough.

Look at the ham happening here. And that’s only a still image. Image via Bustle

Falling Inn Love is Netflix’s version of a Hallmark movie. Now, let me start by saying that, you’re reading a review on a site about movies. You probably enjoy well-written stories, well-directed action, twists and turns…Hallmark has no truck with that sort of thing. They are predictable in the extreme. So much so that if you google “Hallmark movie drinking game” you get dozens of results like this:

falling inn love

Image via Country Living Magazine


So, that should make Netflix’s job easy, right?


Directed By: Roger Kumble

Written By: Hilary Galanoy and Elizabeth Hackett

Starring: Christina Milian, Adam Demos, Jeffrey Bowyer-Chapman, Anna Jullienne, and Claire Chitham

When city girl Gabriela (Milian) spontaneously enters a contest and wins a rustic New Zealand inn, she teams up with bighearted contractor Jake Taylor (Demos) to fix and flip it. Sparks fly, but will romance bloom?

Lower Your Expectations

First things first, if you go into Falling Inn Love expecting an awards-worthy film, you’re making a mistake. If you go into expecting a good film….yeah, that’s not going to be a win either.  If you’ve never seen a Hallmark movie, first of all, well done. Secondly, they are a strange world unto themselves. I deliberately didn’t say “This review will be spoiler-free” because there are no plot points to spoil. Will Gabriela and the Dollar Store Hemsworth fall in love? Of course they will! Will she face jeopardy? No, not really, this is the lowest of low stakes world. A world where someone can drop everything and fly to New Zealand as if money is no object. It doesn’t really have a villain as such. There’s an uptight lady with a competing guesthouse but she’s not so much an antagonist as a comedic annoyance.

No…Lower than That

What do 90% of rom-com protagonists have in common to make them relatable? Clumsiness! Gets you that bonus slapstick too. So, of course, Gabriela is clumsy.

falling in love

Image via The Avocado

She carries out a whole conversation while in a headstand but they still make her wobble comedically when she moves to standing on one leg. That sort of shorthand laziness extends to the rest of the cast. There’s a guy who watches rugby and that’s all he does because all Kiwis in film are legally required to be rugby fans. Gabriela’s douchey boss in America is called Chad. Because of course he is.

Down A Little More…That’s It

Gabriela has a boyfriend at the start of the movie, but why? Only the writers know. He orders her salad in a restaurant without asking her what she wants. They’ve been together for two and a half years but he won’t move in with her. The man has more red flags than a Chinese military parade.

What does her job involve? I don’t know, but it apparently pays enough for a fancy apartment and last minute flights to New Zealand despite her being so unimportant to her boss that they don’t even tell her that no one is coming in the office until 10:30 when she starts at 9.

Thankfully her pay isn’t important in New Zealand because everyone in town is insanely generous and nice. They love nothing more than to give stuff away for free because…reasons.

falling inn love

Image via The New York Times

And Yet…

So, is Falling Inn Love terrible? Objectively yes, but from that view ALL Hallmark films are terrible. The trick is not to treat them like you would a regular film. Firstly, don’t watch them alone. The best way to see Hallmark movies is with other people. You have to treat them like Mystery Science Theater 3000 Or Rifftrax. Falling Inn Love‘s formulaic nature suits that perfectly. You can joke over-the-top and you won’t miss anything important. Once, the person I was watching a similar movie with pointed out the similarities to Get Out and it became tremendous fun. The matchups with Get Out or The Wicker Man are so frequent I’m half-convinced they aren’t unintentional. At one point Gabriela sneezes in town and FIVE people arrive at her house with a doctor, soup and honey. (Honey from Jake’s beehive, because he’s also a beekeeper. And a handyman. And a kids rugby coach. And a fireman. It’s like the writers couldn’t decide on their hunky guy stereotype and gave him them all.)

Within days, it seems like everyone in town is Gabriela’s friend. Only cults are that welcoming. You may want to think about running with that idea and drinking every time someone looks like they’re from Midsommar…I can recommend it, although your liver may disagree.

Image via The Spinoff

Final Thoughts

Can I recommend this movie? Well, it’s simplistic to the point of brain damage, patronizing to both men, women, and goats. So, it’s not something I could grade above an F as a film.

But I highly recommend watching it as a fun way to spend 90 minutes. The cast is all lovely, the countryside of New Zealand hasn’t looked as enticing since Lord Of The Rings and the film bimbles along its silly little way without any dawdling. I wasn’t bored while watching it. Also, the goat was actually pretty funny.

falling inn love

And the goat gets married too. *eye roll* Image via Cosmopolitan

For what it’s aiming for, Falling Inn Love absolutely succeeds. Whether what it’s aiming for is a noble target is another matter entirely.

Actual Grade: F

Entertainment Value Grade: B

Follow MovieBabble on Twitter @MovieBabble_

Thank you for reading! What are your thoughts on Falling Inn Love? Comment down below!

If you enjoyed this article, subscribe to MovieBabble via email to stay up to date on the latest content.

Join MovieBabble on Patreon so that new content will always be possible.

Related Articles


'The Devil All The Time' Has All the Star Power, Not Enough Shine | MovieBabble September 21, 2020 - 3:04 pm

[…] as a sort of anthology of different stories that end up fitting together. Some favorites include Love, Actually and Hail Caesar!, but this is by no means an uncommon trope. It’s simply hard to pull off, […]

'Spiral' is Excellent Queer Commentary Through a Horror Lens | MovieBabble September 16, 2020 - 5:55 pm

[…] we follow Malik (Jeffrey Bowyer-Chapman) as he moves to a small town with his partner Aaron (Ari Cohen) and Aaron’s sixteen-year-old […]

Film Review - The Legacy of the Bones (2020) | MovieBabble April 18, 2020 - 12:10 pm

[…] last but not least, the sort of complex serial killer with a taste for the melodramatic that is a hallmark of this sort of […]

TMP October 1, 2019 - 12:07 am

Dollar store Hemsworth 😂
The one thing I enjoy about bad movies is that their reviews are quite entertaining to read. Thanks for sharing

J. Kolb September 9, 2019 - 10:43 am

True, true! But, having watched both Lifetime and Hallmark movie (sometime the need to be entertained), this was way better than a Hallmark.

mlrover September 2, 2019 - 12:12 pm

I was curious about it, so thanks for saving me time!

Angela September 2, 2019 - 8:59 am

LOL, LOL, LOL. We don’t watch them because they’re good… we watch them because they’re terrible… and so formulaic it’s almost as if those scripts, in addition to constantly being repurposed, seem almost as if they’ve been cranked out of “fill in the blanks” software.

Nick Kush August 31, 2019 - 1:03 pm

Join the MovieBabble staff:

Like MovieBabble on Facebook:

Follow MovieBabble on Instagram:

Follow MovieBabble on Twitter:


Leave a Comment Below!

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: